« History's Greatest Bloopers: One Small Step | Junta Gatherer: Right Bolshevik Degeneracy »
April 25, 2007
Blame the Speech Not the Tactic?
(America-centric, sort of). The news program 60 Minutes here in the USA recently profiled the "Stop Snitchin'" theme of rap music which basically warns inner city, typically African-American, kids not to report crime to the police. Interviews show this is carrying some weight. But at one point host Anderson Cooper notes that many of the teens being interviewed have lost trust for the police already due to (as I recall the words roughly) "behavior of the police in enforcing the drug laws". Bingo! But they leave that thought to pass by -- with only a brief comment by a kid on being stopped and harassed for no reason -- to pursue more attacks on rap lyrics, with disturbing inclinations for free speech.
Bad messages need fertile soil. The "drug war" (and to a great extent enforcement of gun-carry laws which, hello Europe, we do have) are essentially licenses to harass minority group members (because for a variety of reasons white people in the USA would never stand for aggressive enforcement of these rules in their own areas). The underlying danger is not only that such law enforcement habits perpetuate the image of blacks as irreducibly violent (guns) and irrational (drugs) but they also require the physical intrusion of the home and of the body through searches, while providing easy law enforcement successes. This insures great incentives to stop people and cars readily, to unpleasantly interrogate and bodily invade, to find excuses for arrests, and to militarize law enforcement with lethal consequences using anti-gang and anti-gun explanations. The last alone has caused numerous unnecessary deaths and harassment.
I am sympathetic to those who say there are too many complaints about racism in the United States and disagree with those who complain that real change has not happened. But there is still a rule where it is operative: any law that allows disproportionate and aggressive targetting of minorities will lead to that result. At least today.
Posted by Matthew Hogan at April 25, 2007 08:54 AM
Filed Under:
American Culture
Comments
With a few switches, you could pretty much write the same thing about Arabs and France.
The main nuance I would work on is:
I am sympathetic to those who say there are too many complaints about racism in the United States
I am less in the case of France. I certainly wouldn't deny there are way too many (Arab) losers who aren't honest with themselves and put it systematically on racism and there are some civil rights movement who really have no idea which battles to pick and which ones to just let pass. But there definitely is a case of systematic discrimination against which nothing is being done.
Ok this was not your topic, but since the resemblance was there...
Posted by: Shaheen
at April 26, 2007 01:27 AM

RSS



